ThirdPartyCopy

Introduction

The third-party-copy sub-group of the DOMA working group is dedicated to improving bulk transfers between WLCG sites. Currently, the focus is on finding viable replacements to the GridFTP protocol. This is proceeding along in the following three phases:

• Phase 1 (deadline 31 December 2018): Survey available replacement protocols. Common storage implementations (EOS, DPM, dCache, standalone Xrootd, StoRM) aim to have at least one production site enable a non-GridFTP third-party-copy. Compatibility and performance tests are performed.
• Phase 2 (deadline 30 June 2019): All sites providing more than 3PB of storage to WLCG experiments are required to have one non-GridFTP endpoint in production.
• Phase 3 (deadline 31 December 2019): All sites providing storage to WLCG experiments must provide a non-GridFTP endpoint.

One page plan or mandate is also in PDF

To join the group, please subscribe to the following wlcg-doma-tpc e-group. We are actively looking for additional sites - particularly production sites - to participate in the group.

Meetings can be found in the DOMA indico category

Participants

The DOMA sub-group has the following participants (please add your own name!):

• Alessandra Forti (ATLAS, co-coordinator)
• Brian Bockelman (CMS, co-coordinator)
• Mario Lassnig (ATLAS, Rucio)
• Thomas Beermann (ATLAS, Rucio)
• Andrea Manzi (FTS, gfal2)
• Edward Karavakis (FTS, gfal2)
• Paul Millar (dCache)
• Fabrizio Furano (DPM)
• Andy Hanushevsky (xrootd)
• Andrea Ceccanti (StoRM)
• Xavier Espinal (CERN, LCG)
• Wei Yang (ATLAS, xrootd)
• Horst Severini (ATLAS, xrootd)
• Dmitry Litvintsev (Fermilab, dCache)
• Albert Rossi (Fermilab, dCache)
• Shawn McKee (AGLT2, dCache)
• Pepe Flix (PIC, CMS)
• Saul Youssef (NET2, ATLAS)
• James Walder (ATLAS, RAL)

Current Activities

The third-party-copy subgroup is working on two potential TPC protocols for the WLCG:

• Xrootd
• HTTP / WebDAV
• Token authorization testbed

The above links contain information about progress in deployment and testing.

For automated testing of participating sites, we have setup a DOMA-specific Rucio instance.

Monitoring

Rucio has a Kibana instance associated that can be used to create dashboards targeted to specific monitoring. For example if we want to monitor checksums, or DPM to dCache-only transfers etc....

• DOMA Kibana dashboards
  • Transfer volume
  • Functional Tests with dteam X.509, Functional Tests with WLCG OIDC, Functional Tests with TAPE
  • Stress tests transfers, Stress tests throughput, Stress tests 10k files
  • Daemons activity
• FTS monitoring
  • FTS (fts3-devel) monitoring, grafana
  • ATLAS FTS Active Connections, ATLAS CERN source, ATLAS CERN destination
• Rucio DOMA instance
  • configuration, logs
• ATLAS TPC functional tests
  • xrootd functional tests
  • http functional tests
• WebDAV smoke testing
  • https://github.com/paulmillar/http-tpc-utils
• XrootD smoke testing
  • https://github.com/alrossi/xrootd-tpc-utils

The GitHub repository above contains python code and example .json configurations for running xrootd TPC tests using a locally installed xrdcp client. The tests can be run in two different modes: (a) using a reference server, where a file is uploaded to an endpoint, then TPC is run to and then back from the reference server, ending with a download of the resulting copy; (b) bidirectional TPC between each endpoint in the configuration (N^2), which is essentially like the functional tests. The GitHub README contains information as to how to set the tests up. Feel free to contact arossi@fnalNOSPAMPLEASE.gov with further questions.

Open issues in the FTS monitoring

• Unlike the Kibana pages, the FTS monitoring page does not have a X.509 certificate issued by a trusted CA. The CERN CA certs need to be installed on the browser, https://cafiles.cern.ch/cafiles/

Open issues in the Kibana monitoring

• In the "Rucio DOMA - Transfer Overview" page it's unclear whether the results show PUSH or PULL transfers (or does FTS attempt both?).
  • FTS tries both, but recent gfal2 can be configured use just "HTTP PLUGIN:DEFAULT_COPY_MODE=3rd pull" or "HTTP PLUGIN:DEFAULT_COPY_MODE=3rd push"
• In "Rucio DOMA - Failed Transfer Details" it would be helpful if the payload.transfer-link URL was an active link that took the browser to that page.

Storages and Protocols Configurations

Storage system specific information on third-party copy support, including which version(s) to install and how to configure the service.

• Native xrootd
• DPM
• dCache
• StoRM STOR-1018
• EOS
• ECHO

Sites and contacts

Site	Protocol	Storage	Storage Version	Contact(s)	Experiment supported	test/prod	protocol://hostname:port/path/
NET2	http xrootd	GPFS	XRootD 5.3.0	Saul Youssef, Augustine Abaris, Wei Yang	ATLAS	test	http://atlas-dtn4.bu.edu:1094/gpfs1/tpctest (dteam)
NET2	http xrootd	CephFS	XRootD 5.3.0	Saul Youssef, Augustine Abaris, Wei Yang	ATLAS	test	http://atlasgw01.nese.rc.fas.harvard:1094/atlas/ops/tpctest (dteam)
RAL-LCG2	http xrootd	Echo	XRootD 4.9.1	Katy Ellis James Walder	ATLAS, CMS, LHCb, DUNE, dteam	prod/test	Echo production gateway: root://xrootd.echo.stfc.ac.uk/dteam:test/ Echo production gateway (workaround for XRootD <4.11): root://echo.stfc.ac.uk/dteam:test/ Test gateway for DOMA: https://ceph-gw8.gridpp.rl.ac.uk:1094/dteam:test/ Old DOMA test gateway https://ceph-test-gw683.gridpp.rl.ac.uk:1094/dteam:test/ Production gateway to be setup: https://xrootd.echo.stfc.ac.uk/dteam:test/ S3 is separate from the XRootD endpoint. To use S3 directly: https://s3.echo.stfc.ac.uk/{your-bucket} (credentials available by request).
PRAGUELCG2	http xrootd	DPM	1.14.1	Petr Vokac	ATLAS, DUNE, dteam, wlcg	prod	https://golias100.farm.particle.cz:443/dpm/farm.particle.cz/home/dteam/tpc-test root://golias100.farm.particle.cz:1094/dpm/farm.particle.cz/home/dteam/tpc-test gsiftp://golias100.farm.particle.cz:2811/dpm/farm.particle.cz/home/dteam/tpc-test https://golias100.farm.particle.cz:443/dpm/farm.particle.cz/home/wlcg root://golias100.farm.particle.cz:1094/dpm/farm.particle.cz/home/wlcg gsiftp://golias100.farm.particle.cz:2811/dpm/farm.particle.cz/home/wlcg
UKI-SCOTGRID-GLASGOW	http xrootd	DPM	1.8.10	Sam Skipsey	ATLAS, dteam	prod	https://svr018.gla.scotgrid.ac.uk/dpm/gla.scotgrid.ac.uk/home/atlas/atlasscratchdisk/ https://svr018.gla.scotgrid.ac.uk/dpm/gla.scotgrid.ac.uk/home/dteam/ Note: test more bleeding edge DPM instance will be added in near future, this is the production DPM
UKI-LT2-Brunel	http xrootd	DPM	1.13.0	Duncan Rand, Raul Lopes	ATLAS, CMS, dteam	prod	https://dc2-grid-64.brunel.ac.uk/dpm/brunel.ac.uk/home/dteam/wlcg-tpc root://dc2-grid-64.brunel.ac.uk:1094/dpm/brunel.ac.uk/home/dteam/wlcg-tpc
UKI-NORTHGRID-MAN-HEP	http xrootd	DPM	1.13.0	Alessandra Forti	ATLAS, LHCb, dteam, SKA	test	https://vm33.in.tier2.hep.manchester.ac.uk:443/dpm/tier2.hep.manchester.ac.uk/home/dteam root://vm33.in.tier2.hep.manchester.ac.uk:1094/dpm/tier2.hep.manchester.ac.uk/home/dteam
UKI-NORTHGRID-MAN-HEP	http xrootd	DPM	1.13.0	Alessandra Forti	ATLAS, LHCb, dteam, SKA	prod	https://bohr3226.tier2.hep.manchester.ac.uk:443/dpm/tier2.hep.manchester.ac.uk/home/dteam root://bohr3226.tier2.hep.manchester.ac.uk:1094/dpm/tier2.hep.manchester.ac.uk/home/dteam
UKI-NORTHGRID-LANCS-HEP	http xrootd	DPM	1.13.0	Matt Doidge	ATLAS, dteam	prod	https://fal-pygrid-30.lancs.ac.uk:443/dpm/lancs.ac.uk/home/dteam root://fal-pygrid-30.lancs.ac.uk:1094/dpm/lancs.ac.uk/home/dteam
TOKYO-LCG2	http xrootd	DPM	1.12.1	Tomoe Kishimoto	ATLAS, dteam	prod	https://lcg-se01.icepp.jp:18443/dpm/icepp.jp/home/dteam root://lcg-se01.icepp.jp:1094/dpm/icepp.jp/home/dteam gsiftp://lcg-se01.icepp.jp:2811/dpm/icepp.jp/home/dteam
CERN DPM trunk testbed[*3][*2]	gsiftp http xrootd	DPM	1.13.1	Fabrizio Furano	ATLAS, CMS, LHCb, dteam	test	Base path: https://dpmhead-trunk.cern.ch/dpm/cern.ch/home/ gsiftp://dpmhead-trunk.cern.ch/dpm/cern.ch/home/ root://dpmhead-trunk.cern.ch//dpm/cern.ch/home/ dteam: https://dpmhead-trunk.cern.ch/dpm/cern.ch/home/dteam ATLAS path: https://dpmhead-trunk.cern.ch/dpm/cern.ch/home/atlas/domatests gsiftp://dpmhead-trunk.cern.ch/dpm/cern.ch/home/atlas/domatests root://dpmhead-trunk.cern.ch//dpm/cern.ch/home/atlas/domatests
CERN DPM release candidate testbed[*2]	gsiftp http xrootd	DPM	1.13.2	Fabrizio Furano	ATLAS, CMS, LHCb, dteam	test	Base path: https://dpmhead-rc.cern.ch/dpm/cern.ch/home/ gsiftp://dpmhead-rc.cern.ch/dpm/cern.ch/home/ root://dpmhead-rc.cern.ch//dpm/cern.ch/home/ dteam: https://dpmhead-rc.cern.ch/dpm/cern.ch/home/dteam ATLAS path: https://dpmhead-rc.cern.ch/dpm/cern.ch/home/atlas/domatests gsiftp://dpmhead-rc.cern.ch/dpm/cern.ch/home/atlas/domatests root://dpmhead-rc.cern.ch//dpm/cern.ch/home/atlas/domatests
DESY-prometheus [*]	gsiftp http xrootd	dCache	5.1.0-SNAPSHOT	Paul Millar	ATLAS, CMS, LHCb, ALICE, dteam	test	https://prometheus.desy.de:2443/VOs/atlas https://prometheus.desy.de:2443/VOs/cms https://prometheus.desy.de:2443/VOs/dteam ...etc... root://prometheus.desy.de:1095/VOs/atlas root://prometheus.desy.de:1095/VOs/cms root://prometheus.desy.de:1095/VOs/dteam ...etc...

DESY-DOMA	gsiftp http	dCache	5.2.1	Christian Voss (& Paul Millar)	ATLAS, CMS, LHCb, ALICE, dteam	test	https://dcache-se-doma.desy.de:2880/dteam https://dcache-se-doma.desy.de:2880/atlas https://dcache-se-doma.desy.de:2880/cms https://dcache-se-doma.desy.de:2880/lhcb
AGLT2	http xrootd	dCache	5.2.16	Shawn McKee	ATLAS	prod	https://head01.aglt2.org:2880/pnfs/aglt2.org/dteam/ root://xrootd.aglt2.org:1094/pnfs/aglt2.org/dteam
BNL	xrootd	dCache (xrootd proxy)	? 5.2.x	Hironori Ito Jane Liu	ATLAS	prod dteam	root://dcdoor16.usatlas.bnl.gov//pnfs/usatlas.bnl.gov/users/hiroito/testtpc root://dcachetest04.usatlas.bnl.gov:1096//pnfs/usatlas.bnl.gov/data/dteam/
UKI-LT2-IC-HEP	http	dCache	3.2.39	Duncan Rand	CMS, dteam	prod	cms: https://gfe02.grid.hep.ph.ic.ac.uk:2880/pnfs/hep.ph.ic.ac.uk/data/cms/store/test/davs dteam: https://gfe02.grid.hep.ph.ic.ac.uk:2880/pnfs/hep.ph.ic.ac.uk/data/dteam/wlcg-tpc
PIC	http xrootd	dCache	5.2.16	Pepe Flix	ATLAS, CMS, dteam, wlcg	prod	[http] dteam: https://webdav-dteam.pic.es:8448/tpc-test/ ATLAS: https://webdav-at1.pic.es:8446/tpc-test/ CMS: https://door03.pic.es:8459/tpc-test wlcg: https://door02.pic.es:8452/ [xrootd] dteam: root://xrootd.pic.es//pnfs/pic.es/data/dteam/tpc-test/ ATLAS: root://xrootd-at1-door.pic.es CMS: root://xrootd-cms-door.pic.es//pnfs/pic.es/data/cms/tpc-test wlcg: root://xrootd.pic.es//pnfs/pic.es/data/wlcg
CERN EOS	xrootd https gsiftp	EOS	4.7.x (unreleased yet)	Elvin Sindrilaru, Andreas Peters, Xavier Espinal	ATLAS, ALICE, CMS, LHCb, dteam	test	root://eospps.cern.ch//eos/opstest/tpc/ https://eospps.cern.ch:9000//eos/opstest/tpc/
INFN-T1	http	StoRM WebDAV	1.1.0-SNAPSHOT	Lucia Morganti, Andrea Ceccanti - INFN-CNAF	ATLAS (VO dteam)	prod	https://xfer.cr.cnaf.infn.it:8443/dteam
INFN-NAPOLI-ATLAS	http xrootd gsiftp	DPM	1.13.2	Alessandra Doria	ATLAS, dteam, lhcb	prod	https://t2-dpm-01.na.infn.it:443/dpm/na.infn.it/home/dteam root://t2-dpm-01.na.infn.it:1094/dpm/na.infn.it/home/dteam gsiftp://t2-dpm-01.na.infn.it:2811/dpm/na.infn.it/home/dteam
UKI-LT2-QMUL	http	StoRM		Duncan Rand, Dan Traynor	ATLAS, dteam	prod	https://se03.esc.qmul.ac.uk:8443/atlasdatadisk https://se03.esc.qmul.ac.uk:8443/atlasscratchdisk https://se03.esc.qmul.ac.uk:8443/cms https://se03.esc.qmul.ac.uk:8443/lhcb https://se03.esc.qmul.ac.uk:8443/dteam
SLAC	https xrootd	xrootd	5.3.0	Wei Yang	ATLAS, dteam	prod/test	ATLAS: root://osggridftp01.slac.stanford.edu:2094//xrootd/atlas/atlas{data,scratch,...}disk https://osggridftp01.slac.stanford.edu:2094//xrootd/atlas/atlas{data,scratch,...}disk dteam: root://osggridftp01.slac.stanford.edu:2094//xrootd/atlas/tpctest https://osggridftp01.slac.stanford.edu:2094//xrootd/atlas/tpctest
OU	https xrootd gsiftp	xrootd	5.3.1 (4.12.1 on backend storage)	Horst Severini	ATLAS, dteam, wlcg	prod	ATLAS: https:// and root://se1.oscer.ou.edu//xrd/atlas{data, scratch}disk/ dteam: https:// and root://se1.oscer.ou.edu//xrd/dteam/doma/ wlcg: https:// and root://se1.oscer.ou.edu//xrd/wlcg/doma/
SWT2_CPB	https xrootd	xrootd	5.3.1	Patrick McGuigan	ATLAS, dteam, wlcg	prod	ATLAS: {https, root}://gk06.atlas-swt2.org//xrd/[datadisk,atlasscratchdisk] DTEAM: {https, root}://gk06.atlas-swt2.org//xrd/dteam WLCG: {https, root}://gk06.atlas-swt2.org//xrd/wlcg
Nebraska	xrootd, HTTP, GridFTP	HDFS	4.9.0 pre-release	Brian Bockelman	CMS, dteam	test	CMS root://red-gridftp12.unl.edu:1094/store/test/ https://red-gridftp12.unl.edu:1094/store/test/ gsiftp://red-gridftp12.unl.edu/user/uscms01/pnfs/unl.edu/data4/cms/store dteam root://red-gridftp12.unl.edu:1094/user/dteam/ https://red-gridftp12.unl.edu:1094/user/dteam/ gsiftp://red-gridftp12.unl.edu/user/dteam/ [*5]
UNI-BONN	xrootd and xrootd-HTTP	CephFS	5.5.0	Oliver Freyermuth, Peter Wienemann	ATLAS, dteam, wlcg	prod	ATLAS Rucio endpoint in production ( ATLAS-CRIC, WLCG-CRIC) Testing possible via: root://xrootd.physik.uni-bonn.de//cephfs/grid/atlas/user/scratch/ and https://xrootd.physik.uni-bonn.de:1094//cephfs/grid/atlas/user/scratch/ [*6] DTEAM endpoints: root://xrootd.physik.uni-bonn.de//cephfs/grid/dteam/ https://xrootd.physik.uni-bonn.de:1094//cephfs/grid/dteam/ [*7] WLCG endpoints (can be used with tokens / OIDC and X.509): root://xrootd.physik.uni-bonn.de//cephfs/grid/wlcg/ https://xrootd.physik.uni-bonn.de:1094//cephfs/grid/wlcg/ [*7]
FNAL	gsiftp https xrootd	dCache	5.0.0-SNAPSHOT	Albert L. Rossi, Dmitry Litvintsev	dteam	test	dteam Testbed endpoint root://stkendca06a.fnal.gov:1094//pnfs/fnal.gov/VOs/dteam https://stkendca06a.fnal.gov:2880/pnfs/fnal.gov/VOs/dteam/	For the stress tests, use the URLS root://stkendca06a.fnal.gov:1094//pnfs/fnal.gov/VOs/dteam/stress https://stkendca06a.fnal.gov:2880/pnfs/fnal.gov/VOs/dteam/stress These offer persistent on-disk storage (not garbage collected).
BEIJING-LCG2	http xrootd gridftp	DPM dCache	1.10.5 2.16.22	Xiaofei Yan, Xiaomei Zhang	ATLAS, CMS, LHCb, dteam	test/prod	dteam: https://dpmtest.ihep.ac.cn/dpm/ihep.ac.cn/home/dteam/ root://dpmtest.ihep.ac.cn:1094/dpm/ihep.ac.cn/home/dteam/ gsiftp://cmspn001.ihep.ac.cn:2811/pnfs/ihep.ac.cn/data/dteam CMS: root://seadmin.ihep.ac.cn:1094//pnfs/ihep.ac.cn/data/cms/store/test
DYNA-CERN-CLOUD	https	dynafed	1.4.0	Frank Berghaus	ATLAS, DTEAM	prod	https://dynafed-atlas.cern.ch:443/data/cloud/tpc
DYNA-CERN-GRID	https	dynafed	1.4.0	Frank Berghaus	ATLAS, DTEAM	prod	https://dynafed-atlas.cern.ch:443/data/grid/tpc
IN2P3	https xrootd	dCache	8.2.8	Adrien Georget	Atlas, dteam, LHCb	prod	dteam: https://ccdcatli458.in2p3.fr:2880/dteam Atlas: https://ccdavatlas.in2p3.fr:2880/ root://ccxrdatlastpc.in2p3.fr:1094/pnfs/in2p3.fr/data/atlas/ LHCb https://ccdavlhcb.in2p3.fr:2880/lhcb
IN2P3 -Test	https	dCache	8.2.2	Adrien Georget	dteam, ATLAS	test	dteam : https://ccdcalitest11:2880/ Atlas: root://ccdcalitest11.in2p3.fr:1094/pnfs/in2p3.fr/atlas/ Atlas: https://ccdcalitest11.in2p3.fr:2880/pnfs/in2p3.fr/data/atlas/
IN2P3 -DOMA	xrootd	Xrootd	4.11.0	Yvan Calas, Eric Fede	dteam	test	dteam: root://ccxrdli283.in2p3.fr:1094//xrootd/in2p3.fr/disk/dteam/doma
Brussels	https xrootd gsiftp	dCache	4.2.18	Olivier Devroede	dteam	prod	https://maite.iihe.ac.be:2880/pnfs/iihe/dteam root://maite.iihe.ac.be/pnfs/iihe/dteam gsiftp://maite.iihe.ac.be/pnfs/iihe/dteam
Florida	https	Xrootd	4.9.0-rc2	Bockjoo Kim	dteam	prod?	https://cmsio3.rc.ufl.edu:1094/store/user/dteam
SURFsara production	gsiftp https	dCache	5.2.4	Onno Zweers, Alexander Verkooijen	Atlas, LHCb, Alice, dteam	prod	https://webdav.grid.surfsara.nl:2882/pnfs/grid.sara.nl/data/dteam/DOMA-TPC (for webdav door properties including alternative ports, see http://doc.grid.surfsara.nl/en/latest/Pages/Advanced/storage_clients/webdav.html#available-webdav-doors)
SURFsara test	gsiftp https (xrootd untested)	dCache	6.0.0.bb39761 snapshot	Onno Zweers, Alexander Verkooijen	dteam	test	https://dolphin12.grid.surfsara.nl:2882/groups/dteam/DOMA-TPC (webdav doors identical to the above production instance)
NDGF	https	dCache	5.0.5	Jens Larsson (& Vincent Garonne)	dteam	prod	https://dav.ndgf.org:443/dteam/tpc/
NDGF-PREPROD	https	dCache	5.0.5	Jens Larsson (& Vincent Garonne)	dteam	test	https://preprod-srm.ndgf.org:443/dteam/tpc/
LRZ-LMU	https	dCache	4.2.23	Christoph Anton Mitterer Günter Duckeck	dteam	prod	https://lcg-lrz-http.grid.lrz.de/pnfs/lrz-muenchen.de/data/atlas/atlasdynafeddisk/tpc/domatest
TRIUMF	gsiftp https xrootd	dCache	5.2.34	Xinli Liu	ATLAS, dteam	test	dteam: https://webdav.lcg.triumf.ca:2880/dteam https://pps05.lcg.triumf.ca:2880/dteam root://pps05.lcg.triumf.ca:1094/dteam gsiftp://pps05.lcg.triumf.ca:2811/dteam ATLAS: https://webdav.lcg.triumf.ca:2880/atlas https://pps05.lcg.triumf.ca:2880/atlas root://pps05.lcg.triumf.ca:1094/atlas gsiftp://pps05.lcg.triumf.ca:2811/atlas
Caltech	xrootd, HTTP, GridFTP	HDFS	4.10.0-1.osg34.el7	t2admin@hepNOSPAMPLEASE.caltech.edu	CMS, dteam	prod?	CMS root://xrootd.ultralight.org:1094/store/test/ https://xrootd.ultralight.org:1094/store/test/ gsiftp://transfer.ultralight.org//mnt/hadoop/store/test dteam root://xrootd.ultralight.org:1094/store/user/dteam/ https://xrootd.ultralight.org:1094/store/user/dteam/ gsiftp://transfer.ultralight.org//mnt/hadoop/store/user/dteam/
UVic	HTTP	Dynafed	1.6.0	Marcus Ebert Fernando Fernandez Galindo Tristan Sullivan	DTEAM, Belle-II, ATLAS	prod	dteam https://dynafed02.heprc.uvic.ca:8443/dteam/ Belle-II https://dynafed02.heprc.uvic.ca:8443/belle/ ATLAS https://dynafed-atlas.heprc.uvic.ca/dynafed/atlas/ dteam https://dynafed-atlas.heprc.uvic.ca/dynafed/dteam/
KIT	HTTP	dCache	5.2.9	Samuel Ambroj Pérez, Xavier Mol	dteam	test	https://pps-single-webdav-kit.gridka.de:2880/pnfs/gridka.de/tpc/dteam
UCSD	xrootd, HTTP, GridFTP	HDFS	4.11.1-1.osg34.el7	Diego Davila Edgar Fajardo	CMS, dteam	test	CMS root://redirector.t2.ucsd.edu:1094//store/temp/user/ https://redirector.t2.ucsd.edu:1094//store/temp/user gsiftp://gftp.t2.ucsd.edu/cms/store/user/ dteam root://redirector.t2.ucsd.edu:1094//store/user/dteam/ https://redirector.t2.ucsd.edu:1094//store/user/dteam gsiftp://gftp.t2.ucsd.edu/cms/store/user/dteam
MWT2	http	dCache	5.2.15	Judith Stephen	ATLAS	prod	https://webdav.mwt2.org:2881/dteam

TAIWAN-LCG2	httpd, xrootd	DPM	1.13.2	Chien-De Li	ATLAS, dteam	prod	root://f-dpm000.grid.sinica.edu.tw//dpm/grid.sinica.edu.tw/home/dteam/ root://f-dpm000.grid.sinica.edu.tw//dpm/grid.sinica.edu.tw/home/atlas/atlasscratchdisk/ https://f-dpm000.grid.sinica.edu.tw//dpm/grid.sinica.edu.tw/home/dteam/ https://f-dpm000.grid.sinica.edu.tw//dpm/grid.sinica.edu.tw/home/atlas/atlasscratchdisk/
Wisconsin	xrootd, HTTP, GridFTP	HDFS	4.10.1	Ajit Mohapatra Carl Vuosalo	CMS, dteam	test/prod	CMS root://pubxrootd.hep.wisc.edu//store/temp/user davs://pubxrootd.hep.wisc.edu:1094//store/temp/user gsiftp://cms-lvs-gridftp.hep.wisc.edu//hdfs//store/temp/user dteam root://pubxrootd.hep.wisc.edu//osg/vo/dteam davs://pubxrootd.hep.wisc.edu:1094//osg/vo/dteam gsiftp://cms-lvs-gridftp.hep.wisc.edu//hdfs/osg/vo/dteam
Vanderbilt	xrootd, HTTP, gsiftp	LStore	r683	Andrew Melo	dteam	test	gsiftp://gridftp-vanderbilt.sites.opensciencegrid.org/store/user/dteam davs://xrootd-vanderbilt.sites.opensciencegrid.org:1094//store/user/dteam root://xrootd-vanderbilt.sites.opensciencegrid.org:1094//store/user/dteam

[*] Machine rebuilt daily at 06:00 CEST, limited capacity available.
[*2] Limited capacity available.
[*3] May have experimental features
[*5] The red-gridftp12.unl.edu server has higher levels of logging and is simpler for debugging transfer failures. For scale work, replace it with the load-balanced hostname, xrootd-local.unl.edu.
[*6] Limited space (~ 100 TB) available for the scratch endpoints, files not accessed for 7 days are purged each night.
[*7] Limited space (~ 10 TB) available

Features vs Storages and Protocols matrix

Storage/Protocol	Server authentication	Query checksum	Upload-with-checksum	X.509 delegation	Bearer token
dCache/http	No	Yes	Available in 5.0*	Yes	Yes
dCache/xrootd	Yes	Yes	No	No	No
DPM/http	No	DOME 1.10.4	No	Yes	Yes
DPM/xrootd		DOME 1.11.0	No	Yes	No (default)
echo/http
echo/xrootd
EOS/http	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
EOS/xrootd	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
StoRM/http	Available in 1.1.0*	Yes		Available in 1.1.0*	Available in 1.1.0*
xrootd/http	No	Yes	No	No	Yes
xrootd/xrootd	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No
Dynafed/http	Yes	Yes	Depends**	Yes	OIDC: yes, Macaroons**

Server authentication

the data-bearing TCP connection is authenticated using a non-delegated X.509 credential; for example, a host credential or a robot credential.

Query checksum

the ability to query a file's checksum; for example, xrootd kXR_query (with kXR_Qcksum) or HTTP RFC 3230 (Want-Digest request header in HTTP GET or HEAD requests).

Upload-with-checksum

the ability to include a file's checksum when uploading that file's content, with the server rejecting the upload if the content is corrupt; for example, RFC 1544 (Content-MD5 request header in HTTP PUT request).

X.509 delegation

the ability for a client to delegate an X.509 credential to the server, which the server then uses to authenticate the data-bearing TCP connection; for example, GridSite delegation or xrootd GSI delegation.

Bearer token

as the passive server, the server issues a bearer token that the TPC client may pass to the active server. This token is then used to authorise the data transfer. Macaroons and OAuth2 access tokens are examples of such tokens.

*: currently in pre-release **: Depending on the storage backend that Dynafed is federating

Proposed evaluation criteria

The following is a suggestion for how we can evaluate different protocol options. These criteria have not yet been ratified.

The criteria are split into two sections: Requirements and Desirable. The required criteria must be satisfied before a protocol is acceptable, while the desirable criteria are optional.

Requirements:

These criteria must be satisfied.

R1. Well documented

GridFTP builds on a very well establish protocol (FTP), by adding extensions that are well-documented. The OGF standardisation process has yielded both "nominative" (GDF.20 & GDF.47) and "informative" documents (GDF...)

Any replacement protocol must have an equivalent level of documentation.

R2. Multiple implementations

We currently enjoy multiple completely independent implementations of the GridFTP protocol, with various server and client software, used in production, that understand the GridFTP protocol.

Multiple implementations is commonly required by standardisation bodies. It brings several advantages, including a test of the documentation, and avoids a monoculture (and the problems that that brings).

Any replacement protocol must have multiple independent implementations.

R3. Secure as GridFTP

(This is almost an anti-requirement!)

When establishing a GridFTP transfer between sites, the control channel is encrypted, but the data channel is not. Therefore, there is no data privacy and somewhat weaken data integrity.

For example, if an adversary happens to learn the transferred file's ADLER32 checksum and the target data endpoint then she could "injecting" carefully crafted corrupted data, provided the rogue TCP connection is established before the genuine TPC source server connects.

Any replacement protocol must have at least this level of security.

R4. Support multi-VO storage systems

Many WLCG sites have a single storage system that supports multiple VOs. This works fine with GridFTP, as any TPC transfer is authorized based solely on the identity the client presents.

Any replacement protocol must not require sites to run independent storage systems for different VOs.

Desirable:

Although not required, it would be good if a protocol satisfies these criteria.

D1. Improved security

Although GridFTP protocol provides some support encrypted data channels, WLCG has (historically) not used this feature. This decision may be revised in the future.

Although that decision lies outside the mandate of this group, it is something we may consider when choosing a replacement protocol.

Additionally, there are WLCG sites also support non-WLCG communities that have a stronger data secrecy and data integrity requirements than WLCG.

A protocol that provides a stronger data security model may be beneficial to WLCG by:

a) allowing a smooth transition to a stronger integrity and privacy data model,

b) providing an economy-of-scale: more users implies better and more widely adopted software.

It is desirable that any replacement protocol supports transferring data with stronger integrity and privacy than currently available through GridFTP.

D2. Support universal endpoints

Currently, if a storage system supports multiple GridFTP endpoints then all users (from any VO) can use any of these GridFTP endpoints to initiate a TPC transfer. In other words, endpoints are not required to be separated by VO.

It is desirable that any replacement protocol allows an implementation to support all its users with a common pool of endpoints.

D3. Support non-X.509

Considerable effort is underway in exploring and charting alternative authentication models from X.509. Examples of these include EduGain /SAML, OpenID -Connect, https://scitokens.org and Macaroons.

It is desirable that any replacement protocol support transferring data without requiring X.509.

D4. Works with industry

Currently WLCG requires both source and destination TPC endpoints support the GridFTP protocol. However, data is increasingly available through non-FTP protocols; for example, data stored in Amazon S3 storage is available directly using HTTP.

It is desirable that any replacement protocol should support transferring data to industry standard endpoints.

Publications

• "Best practice recommendations Data moving applications, protocols and storage" Aeneas D4.1
• "Systematic benchmarking of HTTPS third party copy on 100Gbps links using XRootD" arXiv:2103.12116
• "Testing the limits of HTTPS single point third party copytransfer over the WAN" CHEP 2019 245 04025
• "HTTP as a Data Access Protocol: Trials with XrootD in CMS's AAA Project" CHEP 2016; J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 898 062042