-- TommasoTabarelliDeFatis - 2015-03-10


UPDATED May 2019
  • Use a Google Doc that you find linked in the table below.
  • Comments to the paper should be classified as type A (style, typos and the like) or B (clearness of the discussion, real or apparent flaws or inconsistencies in the analysis, or in the description of the analysis, ...).
  • Each reviewer should enter the comments, in the two classes above, sorted by line number.
  • As Google Docs allow multiple users to work in parallel, everyone can enter his comments in the proper order.
  • You are encouraged to suggest modifications to the paper, if you feel they are needed, in a propositive form (i.e. refrain from just saying "this should be modified", but make a suggestion about what should be changed if you would like to be of help to the authors).
  • Check publication guidelines if you are unsure of whether a comment is applicable (the guidelines are very instructive and there is a lot to learn about "writable and unwritable" in papers)
  • At the end of the process, the senior reviewer is invited to make the comment style uniform, drop irrelevant comments, resolve any possible conflict between comments from the different readers.
  • The final version should be circulated to the group, for verification, before submission
  • When ready, one of the reviewers (normally the senior one) will submit the comments in CDS on behalf of the group.
  • The review should be posted as a 'comment' to the paper, indicating clearly that this was a CMS Institutional Review from Milano-Bicocca.
  • To post a comment, you visit the paper linkand click on 'Detailed Record'. This gives you access to the full paper and one of the links at the bottom says 'Submit a comment'.

Comment submission and revision - new format (June 2017)

CDS Link Deadline Edit Final set Responses Reviewers
EXO-19-019 16-01-2021 Edit Cds link Cds link Guzzi, Menasce
EXO-18-014 09-08-2020 Edit Cds link Cds link Dinardo, Malvezzi
SMP-20-001 08-06-2020 Edit Cds link Cds link Benaglia, Govoni
EGM-18-001 30-04-2020 Edit Cds link Cds link Massironi, Ghezzi
HIN-19-008 15-02-2020 Edit Cds link Cds link Cetorelli, Dini
HIN-19-009 30-11-2019 Edit Cds link Cds link De Guio, Ragazzi
TOP-15-018 07-10-2019 Edit Cds link Cds link Zuolo, Pedrini
TOP-19-005 30-07-2019 Edit Cds link Cds link Valsecchi, Paganoni
SUS-18-007 06-06-2019 Edit Cds link Cds link Monti, Moroni
HIG-17-033 07-04-2019 Edit Cds link Cds link Guzzi, Menasce
HIN-18-009 24-02-2019 Edit Cds link Cds link Dinardo, Malvezzi
HIG-18-006 07-12-2018 Edit Cds link Cds link Beschi, Brivio, Malberti
TOP-17-001 28-09-2018 Edit Cds link Cds link Benaglia, Govoni
HIG-18-016 07-08-2018 Edit Cds link Cds link Ghezzi, Zuolo
EXO-17-009 06-07-2018 Edit Cds link Cds link Gennai, Malberti
HIN-18-004 07-06-2018 Edit Cds link Cds link Tabarelli, Fiorendi
SMP=16-010 27-04-2018 Edit Cds link Cds link Ragazzi, Dinardo
EXO-17-023 21-03-2018 Edit Cds link Cds link Pedrini, Ciriolo
SMP-16-007 12-02-2018 Edit Cds link Cds link Paganoni, Brivio
EXO-16-056 18-12-2018 Edit Cds link Cds link Moroni, Beschi
SMP-16-018 09-11-2017 Edit Cds link Cds link Menasce, Benaglia
HIG-15-007 08-09-2017 Edit Cds link Cds link Malvezzi, Pigazzini
SUS-17-004 02-08-2017 Edit Cds link Cds link Govoni, Manzoni
B2G-17-003 22-06-2017 Edit Cds link Cds link Ghezzi, Malberti

Comment submission and revision - old format

FSQ-14-002 10-05-2017 Submit/Edit View/Edit     Gennai, Fiorendi
SUS-16-036 04-04-2017 Submit View/Edit View   Dinardo, Tabarelli
HIG-16-027 18-01-2017 Submit View/Edit     Ragazzi, Ciriolo
B2G-16-001 05-11-2016 Submit View/Edit View View Pedrini, Brivio
EXO-16-016 24-08-2016 Step skipped Step skipped View View TTF (single reader)
EXO-14-006 08-07-2016 Submit View View View Brianza, Paganoni, TTF
SMP-14-014 13-05-2016 Submit View/Edit View View Moroni, Pigazzini, TTF
TOP-13-017 11-03-2016 Submit View/Edit View View Menasce, Manzoni
SUS-15-10 25-11-2015 Submit View/Edit View Not found Malvezzi, Fiorendi
HIG-14-040 15-09-2015 Submit View/Edit View View Gerosa, Govoni, TTF
HIG-13-035 14-07-2015 Submit View/Edit View, ViewDraft View Dinardo, Ghezzi
HIG-14-025 05-05-2015 Submit View/Edit View View Brianza, Gennai
HIG-14-006 09-03-2015   View/Edit View View Marzocchi, Tabarelli

Reviewers (updated 2019):

Rotation - Junior/Senior pairs
  • Junior: Benaglia, Cetorelli, DeGuio, Dinardo, Guzzi, Malberti, Massironi, Valsecchi, Zuolo, Pinolini, Boldrini
  • Senior: Dini, Gennai, Ghezzi, Govoni, Malvezzi, Menasce, Moroni, Paganoni, Pedrini, Ragazzi, [Redaelli], Tabarelli

Past reviews (2014):

-- TommasoTabarelliDeFatis - 2015-02-23

Edit | Attach | Watch | Print version | History: r65 | r62 < r61 < r60 < r59 | Backlinks | Raw View | Raw edit | More topic actions...
Topic revision: r60 - 2020-12-17 - AlessioGhezzi
    • Cern Search Icon Cern Search
    • TWiki Search Icon TWiki Search
    • Google Search Icon Google Search

    Main All webs login

This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform Powered by PerlCopyright & 2008-2021 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
or Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? use Discourse or Send feedback