Comparative evaluation of analogue front-end designs for the Phase-2 upgrade of the CMS Inner Tracker

General information

  • Contact person: Natalia Emriskova
  • Author list: tracker author list
  • Reviewers: Jorgen Christiansen, Hans-Christian Kästli, Katja Klein (chair), Flavio Loddo
  • Target journal: JINST
  • Status (April 2021): approved by the TEB, waiting for approval by CMS PubComm

First version of the draft

  • First version of draft, as received on 11th of December 2020: pdf

Comments to the first version of the draft

  • Comments by Katja, 22.12.2020 pdf
  • Comments by Flavio, 28.12.2020 pdf
  • Comments by Jorgen, 14.12.2020 pdf
  • Comments by Hans-Christian, 8.1.2021 pdf

Second version of the draft

  • Second version of the draft (28.1.2021): pdf
  • Reply document: the content related comments are highlighted in the text and for each I explain how is it implemented. pdf

Comments to the second version of the draft

  • Comments by Hans-Christian, 4.2.2021 pdf
  • Comments by Katja, 8.2.2021 pdf

Third version of the draft

  • Third version of the draft (12.2.2021): pdf

Version for TWR and IR

  • Version from 22nd of February 2021, to be used for TWR and IR: pdf
    • Same paper, just renamed for TWR: pdf

Comments from IR (14.3.2021)

Implementation of comments from the IR and designers:

  • Draft version after the TWR and IR: pdf
  • Reply to comments from AFE designers: pdf
  • Reply to comments from Rutgers: pdf
  • Reply to comments from Santander: pdf
  • Reply to comments from Zagreb: pdf

Last checks after IR (16.4.2021)

  • Comments by Katja: txt

Implemented last checks after IR:

  • New version with few modifications after the IR: pdf

Version used for checking of tracker author list (17.4.2021)

  • Almost final version, to be circulated for author list checking: pdf

Final version with tracker author list (26.4.2021)

  • Final version, as approved pdf


KatjaKlein - 2021-04-26

Topic attachments
I Attachment History Action Size Date Who Comment
PDFpdf 12240_RD53A_AFE_evaluation_article_CommentsJC.pdf r1 manage 223.8 K 2021-01-04 - 08:29 JorgenChristiansen Jorgens comments
PDFpdf AFE_designers_annotatedNE.pdf r1 manage 43.9 K 2021-04-06 - 12:31 NataliaEmriskova  
PDFpdf IR_Rutgers_annotatedNE.pdf r1 manage 118.8 K 2021-04-06 - 12:31 NataliaEmriskova  
PDFpdf IR_Santander_annotatedNE.pdf r1 manage 56.5 K 2021-04-06 - 12:31 NataliaEmriskova  
PDFpdf IR_Zagreb_annotatedNE.pdf r1 manage 5033.6 K 2021-04-06 - 12:31 NataliaEmriskova  
PDFpdf RD53A_AFE_evaluation_after_IR_comments.pdf r1 manage 3727.5 K 2021-04-06 - 12:31 NataliaEmriskova  
PDFpdf RD53A_AFE_evaluation_article_v2_annotated_reply.pdf r2 r1 manage 3822.6 K 2021-01-28 - 12:22 NataliaEmriskova The new version of the paper and a reply document.
PDFpdf RD53A_AFE_evaluation_article_v3.pdf r1 manage 3628.2 K 2021-02-12 - 14:41 NataliaEmriskova  
PDFpdf RD53A_AFE_evaluation_article_v6.pdf r1 manage 3727.5 K 2021-04-16 - 15:24 NataliaEmriskova  
Edit | Attach | Watch | Print version | History: r20 < r19 < r18 < r17 < r16 | Backlinks | Raw View | WYSIWYG | More topic actions
Topic revision: r20 - 2021-04-26 - KatjaKlein
 
    • Cern Search Icon Cern Search
    • TWiki Search Icon TWiki Search
    • Google Search Icon Google Search

    Sandbox All webs login

This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform Powered by PerlCopyright &© 2008-2021 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
or Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? use Discourse or Send feedback